radiation vs surgery for prostate cancer

Mariah Brown

written by

Mariah Brown

update on

Greetings! Are you searching for comprehensive information about radiation therapy and surgery for prostate cancer? You’ve come to the right place. As someone with experience in the field of prostate cancer treatments, I understand the importance of finding the right approach for your unique situation. In this article, we will explore the factors to consider when choosing between radiation and surgery as treatment options for prostate cancer.

radiation vs surgery for prostate cancer

Radiation therapy and surgery are two main treatment options for prostate cancer. Both approaches offer significant benefits, but they also present distinct considerations. By diving into the details, we will examine the advantages, potential side effects, and critical aspects you need to be aware of before making a decision.

The Pros and Cons of Radiation Therapy

Types of Radiation Therapy

Radiation therapy utilizes high-energy X-rays or radioactive substances to target and destroy cancer cells in the prostate gland. It represents a non-invasive treatment option that allows patients to maintain their quality of life. There are three main types of radiation therapy commonly used:

External Beam Radiation Therapy (EBRT)

EBRT delivers radiation from an external source targeted at the prostate. Techniques such as three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy (3D-CRT), intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT), stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT), MRI-guided radiation therapy, and proton beam radiation therapy can be part of an EBRT treatment plan. This approach generally takes several weeks, with daily sessions.

Brachytherapy (Internal Radiation Therapy)

Brachytherapy involves the placement of tiny radioactive seeds directly into the prostate gland. This approach can be performed permanently (Low Dose Rate, or LDR) or temporarily (High Dose Rate, or HDR), depending on the recommendation of your healthcare provider.


Radiopharmaceuticals are radioactive substances used to target specific areas affected by prostate cancer. One type targets PSMA (Prostate-Specific Membrane Antigen), while another focuses on bones affected by cancer spread.

Advantages of Radiation Therapy

Radiation therapy offers several advantages:

  • Non-invasive treatment option: Unlike surgery, radiation therapy does not require surgical incisions.
  • Preservation of sexual function: Radiation therapy aims to preserve sexual function, although temporary erectile dysfunction can occur.
  • Minimally disruptive: Radiation therapy allows patients to maintain their regular routines during treatment.

Potential Side Effects of Radiation Therapy

While radiation therapy has numerous benefits, it is crucial to be aware of the potential side effects:

  • Fatigue: Radiation therapy can cause fatigue, generally improving after treatment ends.
  • Urinary symptoms: Some patients experience urinary symptoms such as increased frequency or urgency during treatment.
  • Bowel problems: Radiation can affect bowel function, causing diarrhea, rectal discomfort, or changes in bowel habits.

The Pros and Cons of Surgery

Surgical Approaches

Surgery for prostate cancer involves removing the prostate gland and surrounding tissues. There are several surgical approaches:

Radical Prostatectomy

A radical prostatectomy involves the removal of the entire prostate gland and nearby tissues. This can be performed either traditionally or using minimally invasive techniques such as laparoscopic or robotic-assisted surgery.

Advantages of Surgery

Surgery offers several advantages:

  • Potential for cure: Surgery aims to remove the cancerous tissue entirely, providing a chance of long-term cure.
  • Immediate results: Surgery offers immediate results by removing the tumor.
  • Gland examination: Removing the prostate allows for examination to determine the stage and grade of the cancer.

Potential Side Effects of Surgery

While surgery can be effective, it is important to be aware of the potential side effects:

  • Erectile dysfunction: Surgery can cause erectile dysfunction, which may improve over time.
  • Incontinence: Some patients experience temporary or permanent urinary incontinence following surgery.
  • Risk of complications: Surgery carries the risk of surgical complications, including infection, bleeding, and damage to nearby structures.

Comparing Radiation Therapy and Surgery for Prostate Cancer

Factors Radiation Therapy Surgery
Treatment approach Non-invasive Invasive
Survival rates
  • Varies based on cancer stage and individual factors
  • Generally comparable to surgery
  • Varies based on cancer stage and individual factors
  • Generally comparable to radiation therapy
Side effects Varies based on treatment type; possible side effects include fatigue, urinary symptoms, and bowel problems Varies based on individual factors; possible side effects include erectile dysfunction, incontinence, and surgical complications
Recovery time Varies depending on the treatment type Recovery time can range from a few weeks to several months

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Which treatment option is better: radiation therapy or surgery?

The choice between radiation therapy and surgery depends on individual factors such as cancer stage, overall health, and personal preferences. Consult with your healthcare provider to determine the best treatment plan for your specific case.

2. Can I undergo radiation therapy after surgery, or vice versa?

In some cases, radiation therapy may be recommended after surgery if there are high-risk features indicating an increased likelihood of cancer recurrence. Conversely, surgery may be an option following radiation therapy if cancer recurrence is detected. Your doctor will guide you in making these decisions.

3. Will I experience pain during radiation therapy or surgery?

Radiation therapy itself is generally painless, but patients may experience side effects such as fatigue and discomfort related to urinary or bowel symptoms. Surgery involves anesthesia, so you will not feel pain during the procedure, but recovery may involve discomfort, manageable with medication.

4. How long does radiation therapy take?

The length of radiation therapy varies depending on the specific treatment approach. External beam radiation therapy often requires daily sessions over several weeks, while brachytherapy may be completed within a day or two.

5. Will I need additional treatments after radiation therapy or surgery?

Following radiation therapy, some patients may require hormonal therapy or other treatments to complement the radiation. Surgery may be followed by radiation therapy if cancer recurrences or other risk factors are present. Your healthcare provider will determine the need for additional treatments based on your individual case.

6. Can radiation therapy or surgery cure advanced prostate cancer?

While radiation therapy and surgery can be effective treatment options, they may not completely cure advanced prostate cancer. However, they can help manage symptoms, slow disease progression, and improve survival rates in certain cases.

7. Will radiation therapy or surgery cause me to become infertile?

Radiation therapy may affect sperm production temporarily or permanently, with infertility being a possible side effect. Surgical removal of the prostate gland may also impact fertility, as the prostate produces seminal fluid. Discuss fertility preservation options with your healthcare provider if fertility is a concern.

8. Can I choose active surveillance instead of radiation therapy or surgery?

Active surveillance is a management strategy for prostate cancer characterized by regular monitoring and follow-up appointments. It may be appropriate for low-risk prostate cancer cases where the cancer is slow-growing and not causing symptoms. Active surveillance allows patients to delay treatment until necessary, reducing the potential side effects associated with radiation therapy or surgery.

9. What factors should I consider when deciding between radiation therapy and surgery?

When deciding between radiation therapy and surgery, factors to consider include cancer stage, grade, overall health, potential side effects, post-treatment quality of life, and personal preferences. Consultation with your healthcare provider will provide valuable insight into the decision-making process.

10. Can I receive a second opinion regarding radiation therapy or surgery?

Receiving a second medical opinion is always recommended, especially when making significant treatment decisions. Seek input from another healthcare provider to ensure you have a comprehensive understanding of your options and make an informed decision.


Choosing between radiation therapy and surgery for prostate cancer is a complex decision that should be made in consultation with your healthcare provider. Each treatment approach has its pros and cons when it comes to effectiveness and potential side effects. By understanding the options, considering your individual circumstances, and seeking expert advice, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your health goals and priorities.

It’s important to note that every case is unique, and what’s right for one person may not be suitable for another. To learn more about radiation therapy and surgery for prostate cancer, explore reputable resources such as the American Cancer Society (www.cancer.org) and the Prostate Cancer Foundation (www.pcf.org).

Leave a Comment